Showing posts with label academic wargaming. Show all posts
Showing posts with label academic wargaming. Show all posts

Thursday, 16 April 2026

Wargaming Publishing in 2026

 

Looking back, 2008 was perhaps a pivotal moment for "serious" and historical wargaming literature. Encouraged by John Basset, Tom Mouat and Tony Hawkins, I started to publish books in what became The History of Wargaming Project. This project aimed to  preserve the hobby's roots and create a literature base to support professional wargaming.

The History of Wargaming Project was the most prolific source of "wargaming" titles at time, including bringing out-of-print classics back to life. In 2010, I released several "expanded reprints," such as Joseph Morschauser's How to Play War Games in Miniature (thanks Bob for your work on this). My publishing included an updated edition of Peter Perla’s The Art of Wargaming, which remains a "bible" for both hobbyists and military professionals. Neither Peter Perla and I had any idea that my republication of an academic text from 1992 would become a best seller (within the tiny world of professional wargaming!)

The well-known military publisher Osprey noted the resurgence in wargaming publishing and in 2010 released of Field of Glory: Renaissance. This proved to be a major title and this helped cement Amazon as a primary storefront for rulesets that were previously only available in local hobby shops.

At the start of 2026 wargaming book sales are up and down; more sold, but on average fewer of each title. The exact number of books published each year is hard to work out as some books are published in hardback, paperback and as e-books, then go to second editions, which means they may count more than once in this total. An estimate of the number of titles published is to divide the total by 2.5 to allow for the various editions of the book. Also Amazon’s algorithms sometimes add in books titles that are closely related to ‘wargaming’ such as ‘Military strategy’.  I have not attempted to map the large number of roleplaying rules and even larger number of supporting roleplaying supplements.

With the above caveats in mind, the numbers are as follows:

2010 – 22 titles (the majority were History of Wargaming Project books).

2018 56. The traditional publishers such as Osprey Publishing, Helion & Company, and Pen & Sword dominated. There was also The Portable Wargame (published 2016), One hour wargames and a range of professional wargaming books by The History of Wargaming Project.

2023 104 titles.

2024 132 titles. This included the much anticipated The Third Portable Wargame Compendium.

2025 120 titles.

Currently, in 2026, 90% of wargaming books are now self-published There is a surge in solo wargaming book titles and AI assisted campaign generators. Using LLMs, there is a proliferation of low-quality and often short books. Supported by excellent marketing efforts, they catch many purchasers. It is easy to produce a wargaming book and associated marketing using an LLM.

An approximate breakdown of the wargaming books is as follows:

Rules & Supplements 45%   New systems for skirmish, fleet, and mass-battle gaming.

History & Analysis      20%      Deep dives into historical battles specifically for gamers.

Fiction/RPG     15%      Where "wargaming" is a central plot element or mechanic.

Journals & Logbooks 20%      Low-content books like The Ultimate Wargaming Battle Tracker. These so called ‘ghost titles’ have minimal content and many blank pages

In 2026 there is some frustration that academic wargaming books have low sales (and somehow this is my fault!). Part of this is the high price for some academic books. E.g. Cyber Wargaming: Research and Education for Security in a Dangerous Digital World is £100 hardback and £38 for the Kindle version. Politics of Play: Gaming with the US Military £59, but is now £14 on the Kindle.

One response in the USA has been some books published as pdfs for free. The authors get no money but get the prestige; the publisher of the organisation gets kudos which apparently translates into American government funding. Giving away large numbers of your books apparently demonstrates an organisations mastery of wargaming. Key examples of this are from the US Naval War College and the US Marine Corps.

Matt Caffrey (2019) On War https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/newport-papers/43/

Sebastian Bae (2026) Forging Wargamers: A Framework for Professional Military Education https://www.usmcu.edu/Portals/218/Forging%20Wargamers_web.pdf

So, what is the future of wargaming publishing in 2026? Osprey will continue to publish a range of varying quality wargaming books. Not that expensive, some are excellent such as Frost Grave, but others suffer from lack of play sheets or key rule omissions that make the rules unplayable. There will continue to be a sprinkling of academic works that are expensive, with very limited sales, obscure, but achieve the objective of being seen as high value academic publications. There is no sign the proliferation of AI generated self-published wargaming books is slowing.

In such a crowded market place, brand name is king. Of course, the challenge is establishing that brand name so Amazon and Google find your work and push it out to those their algorithms identify as potential customers.

As for me, The History of Wargaming Project will continue to document the development of wargaming and publish what I consider to be important or merely interesting in this story. The potential level of sales is not one of my criteria when deciding what to publish. I am currently working on seven books at the same time, with a further nine more in my to do list. I also have approximately fifty more books that I could potentially publish if I get the time to write and edit them!

Monday, 19 January 2026

Applying Deception in Wargaming: Introducing Limited Intelligence into Wargames

 

This book covers:

“Guide to applying deception in wargaming”

“Techniques for adding limited intelligence to wargames”

“Fog of war mechanisms for realistic gameplay”

“Practical handbook for wargame designers”

“Innovations in wargaming methods and practice”

“Military deception concepts for hobby and professional wargamers”

Limited intelligence is pivotal in wargaming because it realistically simulates the uncertainty and unpredictability of real-world operations. When players only have partial information, they must make decisions based on assumptions and incomplete data, just as military leaders do in actual conflict. This not only tests their analytical skills and adaptability but also exposes them to the risks and consequences of misjudgement, fostering a deeper understanding of operational complexity. In real warfare, deception exploits this limited intelligence and is used to mislead opponents, mask intentions, and create opportunities.

This books is packed full of practical examples of how wargamers can include limited intelligence, and opportunities for deception, into their games. A wide range of game mechanisms simulating ‘the fog of war’ are discussed; from hidden scenarios, to uncertainty about the enemy order of battle. Uncertainty, also makes hobby games more interesting as it increases the challenge where players are compelled to develop robust strategies for gathering information, interpreting ambiguous signals, and managing the unknown.

This book is published by the History of Wargaming as part of its ongoing work to document innovation in wargaming methods and practise.

The book is available for purchase via Amazon or the Kindle

Sunday, 21 April 2024

New Book: Dark Places- professional wargaming of dark themes

 Stating the obvious, all wargames are dealing with the darkest elements of human experience, that of conflict. However, there is a subset of wargames that are used to explore the darkest elements of conflict. These games are routinely run behind closed doors and rarely, if ever, does the existence of such games reach the public domain, let alone the details. Sometimes these games are part of professional military activity, sometimes part of academic research. Both purposes use the vehicle of designing and playing a wargame as a way to generate different insights from merely reading and attending conferences.

The games in this book were carefully chosen to reduce the risk of offence. They demonstrate the ways of running such games, but without using current or recent conflicts as examples. They include:

Bosnian Mercenary: Gaming the Chaos of the Disintegration of Yugoslavia

WMD 1945

My Aunt’s War: Civilian Experience of War

Between a Rock and a Hard Place: Gaming Surrender

Pickett’s Charge: Using Drama

The Button: Nuclear Decision Making

Exercise Hard Rock: Civil Defence

The Tank Factory: Military Management of the Economy During Wartime

The reader should be clear that these games on dark subjects matter and often have real world consequences. This  book is the first to shed some light on these types of games with actual examples.


Thursday, 17 August 2023

Academic Distain for Wargaming

 

Academic disdain for using wargaming as a tool is a classic example of legacy skills being allowed to override innovation in the academic world. This attitude also explains the near complete absence of academics from professional wargaming; one would expect that military historians would be embedded in professional wargaming, bringing their extensive knowledge to bear. As I wander around the strange world professional wargaming I do not encounter many academic historians, especially after Phil Sabin went to South America.

Stating the obvious, the military and supporting civilian services use wargames for training, education, force development, and practising war fighting. The computer industry uses cyber wargames continually to test business continuity. Education uses games as there is a huge track record of application and value. Emergency planning uses exercises; these use many of the techniques from wargaming. Many disciplines use the tools of wargaming and would think anyone challenging their professional use to be very strange indeed. There are parallels in other disciplines where new tools have been resisted by academics for decades.

I remember GIS (geographical information systems, huge digitised maps linked to spatially referenced databases). The established geographers and planners were anti-GIS as they largely did not have the skills to use it. A planning conference had an academic paper by an established academic guru where the latter looked at one case study and demonstrated Green Belts (an area of protected land in the UK) were shrinking rapidly. Along came the PhD student who used a GIS with the maps of all 14 of England's Green Belts to demonstrate that as a whole, Green Belts were growing.  Obviously, the student was failed. It took perhaps 5 years for GIS to become mainstream and 10 years for the planning world to accept Green Belts were not shrinking.

The computer industry of the 1980’s was a complete shambles, but the tool modelling introduced by the new discipline of systems analysis revolutionised the delivery of IT. I remember saying at my leaving speech from the electricity supply industry that there was no point in me trying to communicate with developers who had not been trained in the new tools. Half of the existing staff then failed the training courses in systems analysis introduced after my departure, so left the industry or were redeployed. Some people could not make the transition and academic consultancy to the IT industry went off a cliff edge as the academics did not initially embrace systems analysis

I could give further examples, such as the arrival of UML modelling in computing, the use of big data to replace tiny case studies, etc. All of these initially struggled for acceptance in the academic world, despite mainstream applications of the new technology.

I regularly talk to academic military historians, but I am often sceptical of the views on anything to do with operational history. They are proficient at narrating key events of an individual soldier’s life, but not when it comes to campaigns and battles. When I talk to a serious wargamer I know they have looked at the military geography, the human terrain, ORBATs, weapon ranges, time, space, the weather etc. A wargame is a model that integrates all these elements, subject to abstraction and generalisation. Unless the academic historian has wargamed the topic, I have no evidence they have evaluated all these different elements of war in their narrative. In the computer industry, it would be inconceivable for someone to talk about a new system without their having used the industry modelling standard tools such as UML. I am perplexed how military historians are tolerated who do not model war.

Over the last 12 months I have looked at the academic literature on Operation Sealion (1940, German non-invasion of England) and found gapping errors in it. The issue is the historians do not seem to have a concept of operational and tactical warfare. One example will suffice to illustrate this. A number of academics suggest that all Hitler had to do was bomb the fixed and mobile radar stations to blind the RAF. This sounds plausible, unless you have an understanding of the operational level of war. Bombers missed their targets routinely by many kilometres. Stukas dive-bombers would then be the best option. They actually stood a 1% of a hit per aircraft. Of course, the Stuka attack pattern makes it very vulnerable to even a fixed Bren gun sited to defend the radar station. The nature of the attack, Stukas stacked up in the sky waiting for their turn to dive, makes them very vulnerable to enemy fighters. A Stuka squadron attack v radar might stand a 10% of getting a single hit, but would loose perhaps 4 Stukas and more damaged. If the Germans had started an all-out dive-bombing campaign on a Sunday, by the end of Tuesday, they would have had almost no Stukas left, and most of the radar stations would still have been working. Serious wargamers understand the constraints of the operational, but from my experience few academic historians do.  

So why are academics reluctant to embed wargaming in their curriculum and academic writing? Judging by innovations in other disciplines, many academics would not be able to make the leap. A lot of the existing military narratives in the academic literature would be now judged inadequate when evaluated through the prism of wargaming. University military history courses that used wargaming would be far more engaging and popular with those that did not. There would be staffing changes as a result of academia embracing wargames.

The academic reluctance to use wargaming has been around a long a time. Paddy Griffith encountered the prejudice of fellow academics against wargamers whilst he was at Sandhurst (1973-1989). Perhaps Paddy’s combination of wargames and military history explains why of all the military history lecturers at Sandhurst from that era, he was the one to influence NATO operational policy. There are real opportunities for academics who can use wargaming; research bids, professional wargaming and student recruitment/ engagement. On a personal note, I am quite happy with the current dearth of academic wargamers; ‘in the valley of the blind, the one-eyed man is king’.